• 9 Posts
  • 690 Comments
Joined 4 years ago
cake
Cake day: November 8th, 2021

help-circle

  • And that’s not lemmy (and every social network’s) only fatal flaw

    Lemmy was founded on the idra that we should be able to escape tyrannical admins like the homunculus /u/spez but it only moved the choke point to the moderators of centralized communities.

    It is an improvement to be sure, but it really lacks the teeth to check the power of moderators because one crucial missing feature and that is

    Automatic, default community aggregation view

    Like imagibe the community called /c/books

    Notice that this was not a link. There is no /c/books community of lemmy.

    There are book communities on certain servers.

    And suppose you want to browse or post to “books”, if you are a normal person you will search for books community and you will go to the most active one.

    This is your typical power concentration pattern. You are certainly free to browse the 10 user books community, but most people who post there are posting to a microscopic proportion of the lemmy “books” audience.

    You would be posting to those few people who change defaults, a largely insignifiant minority of people, you might as well be talking to no one at all.

    I think instead this /c/books

    Should have been a clickable link, and link should show you every post in every books in every instance.

    Without that “automatic community aglomeration as a default view”** and seamless account migration, I think lemmy is destined to become a reddit with extra steps. And it will not thrive as it should.

    ** this is distinct to the “multireddit” concept which is a simple convenience feature that less than 1% of users would know to seek out and setup, therefore it cannot change moderator incentives and peovide general users a way to escape their dominating censorship.


  • Censorship on lemmy is rampant. Even on those instances where modlog is visible.

    Not that modlog is anything user friendly. Severely lacking in search and filtering capability it also seems most modlog actions are autopurged, so if you’re not keeping up with your modlog on a weekly basis then you’re not getting a picture of just how much skewed your picture of reality is being shaped and skewed by the moderators of your instance.

    Moderation calls itself janitorial, but they are the enginneer of tge digital reality you choose to inhabit.

    Despite the “checkbox transparency” of lemmy this is not the cure-all we all wish it were.

    First and foremost, you are a prisoner here the more you participate, the more you have to lose. Because lemmy does not have any kind of seamless account migration. So watch your thoughts or else you could be sent to the memory hole.

    And then we have the dirty trick of “rules” and as we all know, these are cover stories for silencing voices while quieting the voices that remain, by telling them "you are not at risk, YOU wouldn’t ‘spread misinformation’ " or whatever.

    If you want to play a game, read your community rulea and try to find which one is the catch all rules. All rulesets have catchalls that can be argued into justifying any moderator actions.

    And all of that applies to good faith moderation. Bad faith moderation doesn’t have to convince itself of its fair neutrality, it will just use these same system knowingly to obfuscate its own actions.



















  • Well creating an opposibg empire didn’t work out so great.

    Capitalism is a belief system, you can’t beat ideas with guns.

    There’s not going to be an anti-imperialist empire that successfully ends imperialism.

    It exist only because it’s population is cajoled into accepting it as the only viable, profitable option.

    Concentration of power is the social disease, it creates a “all the eggs in one basket” situation where one bandit can seize control of the whole.

    It is a strange paradox that a society built on individual responsibility would be corrupted and usurped by its cooperation mechanism. And that the path to a semblance of decency is to cut down on cooperation to disempower those at the grotesque top.

    And then maintain taboos to prevent tge concentrations fromvforming again. BECAUSE they are too profitable and power.

    Make CEO a crime, make presidents weak, cut off the heads of kings.