I considered leaving Twitter as soon as Elon Musk acquired it in 2022, just not wanting to be part of a community that could be bought, least of all by a man like him – the obnoxious “long hours at a high intensity” bullying of his staff began immediately. But I’ve had some of the most interesting conversations of my life on there, both randomly, ambling about, and solicited, for stories: “Anyone got catastrophically lonely during Covid?”; “Anyone hooked up with their secondary school boy/girlfriend?” We used to call it the place where you told the truth to strangers (Facebook was where you lied to your friends), and that wide-openness was reciprocal and gorgeous.
“Twitter has broken the mould,” Mulhall says. “It’s ostensibly a mainstream platform which now has bespoke moderation policies. Elon Musk is himself inculcated with radical right politics. So it’s behaving much more like a bespoke platform, created by the far right. This marks it out significantly from any other platform. And it’s extremely toxic, an order of magnitude worse, not least because, while it still has terms of service, they’re not necessarily implementing them.”
Global civil society, though, finds it incredibly difficult to reject the free speech argument out of hand, because the alternative is so dark: that a number of billionaires – not just Musk but also Thiel with Rumble, Parler’s original backer, Rebekah Mercer (daughter of Robert Mercer, funder of Breitbart), and, indirectly, billionaire sovereign actors such as Putin – are successfully changing society, destroying the trust we have in each other and in institutions. It’s much more comfortable to think they’re doing that by accident, because they just love “free speech”, than that they’re doing that on purpose. “Part of understanding the neo-reactionary and ‘dark enlightenment’ movements, is that these individuals don’t have any interest in the continuation of the status quo,”
While I agree with absolutely everything in the article, Twitter was already quite bad before Musk, at least for the end user.
The platform excels at letting people shout into an echo chamber, and is easily falling into opinion pits. The fall of Twitter was an inevitability frankly, Musk merely sped things up.
Honestly, I think the idea of echo chamber style social media is slowly on the way out, they have way too much bad PR for way too long to be sustainable anymore, or maybe that’s me being positive.
Either way, social media will be changing, for better or worse within the next few years.
Did Musk take a thing we all loved and smash it? Pretty much.
Haha! I love seeing left wingers pretend that X didn’t have these problems before Elon Musk took over lol
It just wasn’t a problem to them and it was a problem for people they didn’t like (whom they call Nazis, various “-ists” and so on if they dare think differently from them). Now it’s flipped and it’s a problem for them but not the people they don’t like. Every platform needs some form of moderation, but that moderation can run the risk of being too harsh on certain groups depending on the opinions of the moderators. Dorsey himself admitted this was happening at Twitter (being too harsh on legitimate conservative views (not just real Nazis) because the mods didn’t like them) to Congress before it was sold, and he did little to nothing about it. Now the moderation seems to be at the whims of however Elon is feeling on any given day, and due to his own stances, liberals are now getting the brunt of it. It really would be nice to just have somewhere where only the very extremes of left and right, and any actual illegal content, would be moderated out and the mods could keep to that no matter what “side” they or ownership is on. But I know that’s just a pipe dream.
And is it ethical to keep using it?
How is this even a debate? No! The answer is fucking “no”!
I left when Musk started paying Andrew Tate. Never looked back
I’ve lost to faith in several self proclaimed leftists over this that I have followed (not on Twitter) for years. They cannot let go of what they have “built for themselves” there and refuse to accept their own actions have consequences when they wear their blue checkmark with pride like storm troops wore their swastikas back in the 1930s. Everything is a class struggle except when it would impact them. Then it conveniently becomes a mere transaction between them and a provider and you shouldn’t think too much about it because it benefits them. And if it benefits them, it benefits the cause, right? Right???
It’s not, but the people who care about ethics and would answer yes, already left.
So now it’s just everyone else. Articles like this aren’t really aimed at us.
Asking that question is the first step people need in order to finally come to that conclusion. We all just completed the process a loooooong time ago.
Twitter got bought literally less 2 years, we all fucking remember.
Who is this article for? 1 year olds?What?
And is it ethical to keep using it?
No. And I’ll go further: if you still use it, at the very least you’re an entitled arsehole ranking their own dopamine over the well-being of everyone else. And you deserve to be treated as such.
But I’ve had some of the most interesting conversations of my life on there, both randomly, ambling about, and solicited, for stories:
They’re weighting the emotional investment in the platform, caused by their earlier interactions, with it, as if it mattered when deciding future usage. It does not; that’s a fallacy = stupid shit called “sunken cost”.
fast realised that I would never get 70,000 followers on there like I had on Twitter. It wasn’t that I wanted the attention per se, just that my gang wasn’t varied or noisy enough
Refer to what I said about the title.
Stopped reading here. This article is a waste of my time.
I won’t even click on links to Twitter anymore. I had an account in the beginning but even back then the signal to noise ratio was stupid low. Now It’s all bots and nazis.
it’s always been full of hatred; it just had a trust and safety team that attempted to do something about it before elon.
Before WW1 many people left the area because they didn’t want anything to do with war. The area became more “hawkish” let’s say. Before WW2 many people left the area because they didn’t want anything to do with ANOTHER war. Also, some of them were literally being persecuted. The remaining people trended towards a certain persuasion.
When Elmo bought Xwitter people left. Guess who remained? When he invited the racists back, guess who remained? When he invited the banned people back, guess who remained?
Xwitter has always been shit, but when you cut the corn and peanuts out it’s all shit.
Well I mean everybody abandoned ship when musky took over, and then as he was shooting holes in the bottom of the boat, even more people left. Then he started giving priority access to the top deck for anyone who would pay for the privilege. Now the boat is half filled with water and still flooding. Honestly I’m a surprised that the boiler hasn’t exploded by now, what with how much of the engineering staff he fired. I think the only people keeping that thing running are the ones who literally just can’t escape.
🧑🚀🔫🧑🚀
Who cares about ethics in social media? The question is, if you want to become a hateful hyperbole.
Musk and no, anyone still using it is fine with its issues
Even if it wasn’t full of hatred, it’s still a pretty big waste of time, even before the Muskrat was in charge.
Meh it had some used back then. I used it to keep track of local news and police. Things would often show up hours before other sources. Local schools pushed closing and such, making it more convenient.
Twitter should just merge with Truth Social at this point. So that way people will know what kind of platform they are engaging with.
Oh boy, what a marvelous idea. This could save the tanking DJT stock and allow them to prolong the scam. It would allow Trump to close the Truth Social scam with a seemingly sensible move. Elon is supposed to be in his cabinet anyway. It’s perfect.
Stop upvoting this bullshit. Both of these headlines have patently obvious answers. This is click bait.
